Forum

Forum » Suggestions

Defense

  1. ⓣⓐⓘⓝⓣⓔⓓ @ 08 Sep 2011 02:26:27 PM
    :facepalm:
    Nitroed I doubt that you was a best defense player in MD1.

    The problem would be Defense whores would train Defense to beat everybody, none of their training would be useless to one group.

    Can you explain how????


    As I know in my less than 1 years on play

    Defense whore needs

    1> to train defense to won over spd/str player

    2> to train HP i.e; Leveling, to won a def/hp battle

    AM I RIGHT OR AM I RIGHT?

  2. Nitrored @ 08 Sep 2011 02:36:28 PM
    You are correct-ish under today's system. I am of course speaking of the suggested system in this thread.

    If defense effectively raises hitpoints, then you only train defense.
  3. Nitrored @ 08 Sep 2011 02:52:46 PM
    I dont think my original post will drive it home for you Anubis. So elaborate a little more.

    ****************
    [NBK] ANUBIS
    495 posts
    08 Sep 2011 06:40:23 AM
    ... 1 HP per 1 mill stat ...
    ****************

    1 level gives 50 hitpoints, 50 hitpoints are gained from 50mil stats in your idea.


    In the mid 400s a player can train 2.5mil stats per 1k points used, or 50mil stats for 20k points.
    Granted in the mid 400s leveling is still pretty cheap and easy... but as you get into the high 400s and low 500s it gets to be around 10k points a level and climbs FAST.



    A level 500 defense whore can train 20k points on defense, and gain 50mil defense and 50 hitpoints. Before those 20k points on level would have gained zero stats and 100 hitpoints.

    A level 530 defense whore can train 20k points on defense, and gain 50mil defense and 50 hitpoints Before those 20k points on level would have gained zero stats and 50 hitpoints. Why would he ever point level again, since training defense basically doubles the effectiveness of his points.
  4. [H~I] HCNILF @ 08 Sep 2011 03:32:22 PM
    G in less than 1 year of playing MD you have demonstrated to everybody how dumb and stupid you are!
  5. ⓣⓐⓘⓝⓣⓔⓓ @ 08 Sep 2011 04:08:47 PM
    ^^

    atleast you know the truth who is what :haha:
  6. ⓣⓐⓘⓝⓣⓔⓓ @ 08 Sep 2011 04:13:06 PM
    and my suggestion why we are discussing this again and again?

    We all know Dave will not going to change anything. If you like play and if you do not like the system still play.
  7. Brody171 @ 08 Sep 2011 10:09:37 PM
    I think the system is fine how it is.

  8. Lolly Squirrel @ 09 Sep 2011 12:18:24 AM
    Yet again.

    A defense account who is 4 levels. And has twice the defense of the person he is attacking, deserves to lose, because the other player has higher speed?

    How does that make sense? What justice is that? O you trained more, and leveled more; and you lose?

    Alright. Lets all play the role of bashing down suggestions instead of helping to better the system.

    But its what the fuck ever. :sick:
  9. Shift @ 09 Sep 2011 02:47:23 AM
    I think people understand why the thought crossed into your head Anubis, but after reading opinions of others, and especially nitro's final explanation, it becomes pretty clear why your idea just isn't feasible.
  10. [H~I] smoof.watermelon @ 09 Sep 2011 03:46:26 AM
    "A defense account who is 4 levels. And has twice the defense of the person he is attacking, deserves to lose, because the other player has higher speed?"


    thats what you call encouraging people to stat.

    the new system gives everyone a reasonable oppurtunity to "exploit" each player type. if you are concerned about losing to someone 4 levels lower than you with half the defense as you, you still have 3 ways to get him. 1.) match his speed 2.) train your strength past his defense 3.) put ~6 levels on him.

    you just want a shortcut. because you already have relatively high level, it would be to your advantage to get more HP by training defense.

    train defense, get hp = double dipping
  11. [H~I] smoof.watermelon @ 09 Sep 2011 03:47:31 AM
    and thats me speaking from a defense account.
  12. Nitrored @ 09 Sep 2011 12:26:29 PM
    Defense is the ability to absorb damage, you take all the enemies strength and damage and reduce it to 1, assuming you are defensive enough. That is all it does.


    Speed is the ability to be fast, fast enough to hit first, and fast enough that instead of ABSORBING a hit you move the fuck out of the way.


    If you were to learn boxing for instance, one of the first things youd learn is stance and being light on your feet so you can MOVE. The concept of speed effecting defense kind of makes sense.


    In this sense defense whores have to way to 'extend' their fights long enough for them to win. Training to absorb more blows via leveling, or training to get the fuck out of the way and absorbing less hits via speed.
  13. Lolly Squirrel @ 09 Sep 2011 12:47:20 PM
    Using the boxing metaphor, would you rather fight King Hippo or Muhammad Ali?

    And let me ask you this, if someone is faster then you do you trade them punch for punch? No. Thereforth speed should effect your hits in a row, a chain of attacks on your part based on your speed if someone has 10X your speed they should shoot you 10 times in a row, then switch.

    Agility should effect your hit/miss ratio. If someone has 10 X your agility, you should have a 1 in 4 chance of hitting them. And they should have a 4 to 1 chance of hitting you.


    Hell that would make more sense then the current attack system. But thats just IMO.
  14. Nitrored @ 09 Sep 2011 01:23:11 PM
    The game does blow for blow... it really would be the same if 2% of the time you got to hit twice in a row.
  15. Lolly Squirrel @ 09 Sep 2011 01:26:49 PM
    I know thats what i'm saying.

    What fight have you seen where it goes hit for hit. Its usually the faster guy gets more hits in.

    Hell i'm just elaborating on your RL concept :haha: