Forum
Forum » SuggestionsDefense giving a 2% boost to Speed?
- Author
- Post
-
This was more a random thought, Im not even sure if Id +1 or -1 it yet

A defense whore, depending on ones view point, has a penalty or advantage of training a 3rd stat to gain a 2% advantage over players of their same type, other defense whores.
Would it make sense to give the str/spd players the same type of option? Take one of the unused by str/spd players stats and have it give them a 2% advantage in beating other str/spd players (increasing speed a max of 2%)
I was thinking defense because its kind of explainable, if you are defensive, you would be looking for trouble and more ready for it, so even though you have lightning reflexes its faster then sitting their relaxed... something like that.
In terms of perfect balance i think levels might make more sense, but is also less explainable and i think str/spd would hate it more.
thoughts? -
ummm move this to suggestiosn
-
Both ways lack logic. Level because of more experience perhaps but even that's far-fetched.
-
with or without the random loss factor we have now on speed? Which is basically the same effect?
wouldn't that be a double loss for str/sp?
-
if you actually consider getting a 2% advantage over other str/spd players a loss ... then sure.
-
a 2% advantage for one is a 2% disadvantage to another.
It would give the str/spe players the same argument the def players have been having..
Why train a certain way for months, years for some for someone to train a couple of weeks and kill you?
I reckon it will just fizz up the champagne that was corked
-
2% isnt going to have somebody who trained for weeks, beat someone who trained for years...
but yes exactly it opens str/spd up to that whole thind defense is debating so much. On the defense side Im about an only one that sees it as a positive, it is, im just one of the few that sees it
But this would be the same type of positive, that most would think of as a negative.
More i think about it the more i think it should be level effecting speed. -
I like this.
-
And actually back to your point Mac, a BETTER defense whore in level could always have lost a slight percentage of the time to lower level defense whore in the old system. The 2% loss factor you guys have brought you into the same random loss factor defense whores had since day 1. So although it felt like a loss that was actually balance in my eyes.
That balanced the old ways, this idea could balance the new ways. Its a matter of perspective on whether it balances by moving you guys positively or negatively. -
I thought of you when I wrote it Anubis
-
2% isnt going to have somebody who trained for weeks, beat someone who trained for years...
Durr, but it's an easy way of explaining how some people see it. In some ways it is a positive, in some ways it's a negative. Each to their own.
What I don't understand in the changes is why complicate a simple attack system?
And I get the positive with defense stuff... Cheaper to train 50M speed to kill someone 10 levels above you than it is to level past them when you're a higher level... Sure, it's positive.. But who likes change?
-
Why don't defence players train strength up while they're at it? Just get us all to train up all three stats.
Come on, even if a speed player could train defence up to gain an advantage in speed why would they when they could just put the stats into speed anyway? Defence players being able to train speed means they don't have to put even more points into gaining levels - it opens up a slightly different style of play to the defence player hoard. -
I'm not for or against, just thinking, I know a few Str/sp HoF players that can only consider the 2% thing a loss, this would just add another loss, however for the majority of players who are not HoF, it would just make winning or losing a random factor even more so?
-
I think thats why I like the idea... why NOT complicate the simple combat system. In a straight fight a look at the HOF pre-determines the winner in each fight. These are simple little very slight boosters, the games is 98% the way it was, and 2% some new strategy.
I mean in all honesty drugs fucked the whole combat system way more ... 30%?!?!
-
I would rather spend 25 K points towards leveling then training speed. Even though i've been FORCED to train speed due to the new system.