Forum

Forum » Suggestions

Tweaking Battle System

  1. Adios. @ 28 Jan 2013 07:08:25 PM
    First of all this is not a suggestion but a discussion and that is why i have not posted this in suggestion forum.

    For the past few weeks and more i have seen people complaining about offline hits also being calculated by the present battle system and to somehow their point of view is correct. That a one man gang can defeat gang having 30+ or many members as he can do more hits on other gang's offline players(leaving online players on a side for now) and can win the battle.

    I have thought of few things to tweak the battle system.

    1) Introducing "MORALE" factor:-

    I was wondering how about introducing another factor in battles that is "Morale".

    How it will work?

    If a higher level account hits a low level account the higher level account will fight with low morale against the low level account and in result he would get more damage than it gets now.
    On the other side the low level account will fight with higher morale and will do more damage to the higher level(I am not saying that it will defeat high level account, just do more damage).

    Its more likely "efficiency".

    Dave can set ranges for every level. Like if its a 5 or 10 level difference between the two fighting accounts then morale from both sides will be 100%.

    How morale will affect?

    The account with lower morale will have its HP drained twice as fast as it does now.
    Or dave can set it to use more energy then it does now.
    (Or some other thing could be done to negatively effect the lower morale account during the battle).


    How will it affect the present battle system?

    The present battle system counts the online/offline successfull hits which is not very good way of solely determining the battler winner.


    How new battle system would calculate?

    The new(tweaked) battle system would calculate points based on morale as well as hits done(hits include online/offline as well as successful and unsuccessful).

    Below figures are just for example to explain the system.

    1) Successful online hit with 100% morale = 10 points. (like two accounts defeating each other while they are within the range of 100% morale).
    2) Successful online hit with <100% morale = 2.5 points.( means higher account killing the low level account).
    3) Successful online hit with > 100% morale = 20 points.(means a low level account beats a high level account online).

    4) Successful offline hit with 100% morale = 5 point.(means two accounts beating each other while they are in 100% morale range when one account is offline).
    5) Successful offline hit with <100% morale = 1 point.(means higher level account beating an offline lower level account).
    6) Successful offline hit with > 100% morale = 3.5 points (means low level account beat a high level account while its offline).

    Similarly we could also calculate some points for unsuccessful online hits with 100%, <100% and >100% morale.
    As well as for unsuccessful offline hits with 100%, <100% and >100% morale.

    Offline hits will have really low points and they would only affect when done in very large quantity so that they don't give a one sided benefit in wars with smaller gangs.

    Unsuccessful hits are also being calculated but they will also have low points outcome but it will give low level players a chance to help their gang in a way to put their effort in those battle points which in the end would determine who won.
    Whereas in present battle system lower levels can't do much in wars to help their gang win battles.

    Moreover this tweaked battle system would encourage accounts to hit other account within their level.
    And it would encourage every level account from level 1 to maximum level to participate in wars and do something for their gang during war.

    Again i would say the above points were just used for example and to show how the system would work.
    If implemented properly it would be calculated according to proper ratios.

    Don't get heated up or upset. Its just a discussion for a new battle system as many of us are not satisfied with present system.

    Constructive criticism and discussion would be appreciated.

    Regards
    нєιѕєивєяg a.k.a ©שסßעס ßעההט :smile:
  2. $$$tormbreaker @ 28 Jan 2013 07:14:00 PM
    I like how well you explained this but I do not aggree with it at all, it will just break the battle system furthur, especialy if HP drains twices as fast for the low morale. I like the idea but think there could be a different approach on it versus a extream health loss for one party.
  3. Adios. @ 28 Jan 2013 07:17:24 PM
    HP degrading twice was just as example or an idea.

    Dave could do something else.

    The main theme is to negatively affect the one with lower morale. (i.e he would consume more resources because he would be figthing with lower morale.).
  4. Insanity™ @ 28 Jan 2013 07:21:21 PM
    I don't agree with this either. It boils down too penalizing long terms players that have built there account.
  5. Adios. @ 28 Jan 2013 07:24:29 PM
    Insanity explain your point.

    How do you think in what ways it would penalize the long term players?
  6. Adios. @ 28 Jan 2013 07:25:19 PM
    and compare this with current battle system.
  7. $$$tormbreaker @ 28 Jan 2013 08:02:54 PM
    I belive its like this you build or buy top accounts to be able to put pain down on anyone if need be, now if someone that is less level than you buy a lot has a chance of beating you due to the "morale" or tweeking you explained it makes it kinda lame. and if they still have no chance of beating you they just do a little more damage to you then the system is kinda pointless anyway.
  8. [#14] Big C @ 28 Jan 2013 08:25:14 PM
    how bout we just roll dice
  9. [°ß°] Hancock @ 28 Jan 2013 09:24:12 PM
    ^:haha:
  10. ⓣⓐⓘⓝⓣⓔⓓ @ 29 Jan 2013 07:40:15 AM
    How about make everything random... a lvl 1 player can kill the Rank 1 player

    i.e; make the higer lvl accounts more shitter
  11. Unethical Ethix @ 29 Jan 2013 10:16:51 AM
    To be honest I like the way it is now in essence.
    The 50k needs to be incorporated with a hit target also maybe. This way lower/mid levels have a job to do in the xp gaining and the higher levels have a job in the hitting.
    Example..First too 50k xp AND 500 hits

    Those numbers are just an example not set in stone. The war also needs to finish once one gang reaches the target as in bars lock, winner announced at update that day and gangs unlocked etc.

    Territories need to be limited to one per war not how it is now as in 10 per war. This way gangs just cant wipe out other gangs total territories and smaller gangs get a chance at keeping whats theirs.
  12. [#14] Big C @ 29 Jan 2013 02:05:09 PM
    we're working out the kinks in Dave's game

    :scream:

    gimmie POINTS!!!!
    I'm not some Q&A flunkie :mad:
    :haha:
  13. Adios. @ 29 Jan 2013 06:31:19 PM
    @Donkiller

    Alright, what if we leave that negatively impacting higher level's at side for now.

    What other pros and cons does this have?
  14. BlackOrchid @ 31 Jan 2013 04:39:21 PM
    Put it back to how it used to be, it was fine before. :weh:
  15. Feel Like Dancin @ 08 Feb 2013 11:40:21 AM
    it could be a good idea