Forum
Forum » SuggestionsREFORM
- Author
- Post
-
The current method of electing staff leaves players in a never-ending cycle of bitching and [alleged] corruption. With open elections and impeachments, Staff would at least have to watch what they do or how they handle things as opposed to now where alleged favoritism play a role on how things are handled. Im not saying,open up admin or gm for votes, but at least FM and Chat Mod should be seats open for voting and impeachment. It also gives the game a brand new element, with virtually minimal hassle. Favoritism card gets thrown out the window and the forums are given back to the players.
-
Are you on drugs?
Staff aren't elected here (except me, I was voted staff at one point but that was long ago). This isnt the USA. -
In the world of sharp knives, you are a spoon darling, try reading the title again, once ur done sounding it out look up the definition on Google
-
You are on drugs!
-
I applied for "Player Guide" on 25 Aug 2011 03:59:59 AM. That's before "Chat Mod" was around. When Chat Mod was created(by Dave) They also assumed the responsibility of Player Guide. I was made MD's first Chat Mod and didn't know it.
-
Just to play with the government analogy, GMs, FMs, and CMs functionally operate in judicial branch of the MD governing hierarchy. As "judges", their job is to read and interpret the "laws" and make unbiased decisions based on them.
If "judges" were elected, it would be in the best interest of the "judge" to make the popular decision, that is decisions that are favorable to the majority of "constituents" and not necessarily the best decision for the game.
So if you look at most developed countries, most judges are appointed and not elected. You might have a few county/local, low level judges that are elected to limited terms, but federal judges are always elected and often times hold lifetime tenures. This is in part to allow judges to make unfavorable decisions without having to be concerned with maintaining their popularity. -
So how do you remove a judge from his/her post? In most countries, this is the job of the legislative branch i.e. the branch that MAKES the laws. In MD terms, this is the Admin. If you feel a GM, FM, or CM is incompetent, biased, corrupt etc. file a formal complaint. Present your grievances and support it with evidence.

-
I have no personal grievances fortunately but I can only speak for myself. I'm sure after reviewing the forums and chatting with fellow players you could find grievances and get to the bottom of them. I also believe an open election would motivate FMs n CMs ( not trying to open up admin and gm) to cherish their position in the game and not take it for granted. Aside from that, I also believe that open elections would bring a new life to the game that it hasn't seen since the existence of territories and gang wars. Players could campaign, be elected, and if they serve their community well, continue to keep their position. On the flip side though, if an under qualified candidate is elected and just doesn't meet the MD standard, they can easily be impeached and the election process begins again for that open spot, I mean let's be real with ourselves for a second, there's plenty of FMs, the absence of one seat will hardly be noticed, just a thought.
-
But by having an election, you're basically saying staff candidates have to play favors to win votes and once they win, player voted impeachments would motivate them as staff to continue to play favors to keep their positions. Its an endless cycle of favouritism. If you can't see that, there's really not much more I can say.
-
For example, if I was campaigning to be staff, and I wanted you to vote for me, what would I do? I'd talk to you and say "Hey Ongrid, I want you to vote for me for staff. What can I do to win your vote?" And you would solicit something that would shift the current state into your favor.
-
of course, ongrid wants an even more corrupt system than it is
-
Why does there have to be favoritism? Can we not be competent enough to vote for the right person, sure I understand what you are saying smoof and if this idea was implemented then the one most popular will win unfortunately.
-
There really wouldn't be room for playing favors as there's not one player on here that would be safe from an impeachment. It's a for the players, by the players kind of deal and staff members doing their job properly would not have anything to worry about, obviously some details would have to be hammered out ( how many votes can initiate an impeachment, can staff vote,etc).I do believe that we are such a tight knit community that permanent leaders (FM n CM) aren't necessary as we are all familiar with the rules of the forums. Why not let the game have a breath of fresh air and open our minds to change that could be fun and productive for our game. You never know, you might find a candidate who helps improve the quality of the forums, we shouldn't fear change, we should embrace it.
-
Who is the most popular player on here?

Is this high school? Are we still running on the "cool" system?
I figured that as a community of adults (mostly) we can choose a competent enough FM and CM, not rely on a persons coolness. Even if you vote for coolness, that coolness will not shine over a competent FM, that's for sure.
-
I suppose you're right
What am I thinking?
This ain't high school